Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Moderna agrees to pay up to $2.25B to settle COVID vaccine patent dispute

Moderna has agreed to pay Genevant Sciences, a subsidiary of Roivant Sciences, and Arbutus Biopharma up to $2.25 billion to settle a long-running legal fight over the technology that made its COVID-19 vaccine possible, the companies said on March 3. Under the deal, Moderna will pay $950 million upfront in July 2026, with an additional $1.3 billion that depends on the outcome of a separate legal appeal. The deal resolves all U.S. and international legal actions accusing Moderna of using lipid nanoparticle, or LNP, a delivery technology owned by Genevant and Arbutus, without permission in its COVID vaccine. Moderna said in a press release that it would not owe the companies any royalties for LNP technology in its future vaccines under the agreement. Lipid nanoparticles act as a tiny protective shell that helps fragile mRNA molecules reach human cells intact, allowing the vaccine to work as intended. Moderna shares jumped more than 10% in after-hours trading, while Arbutus rose 11% and Roivant was up about 1 percent. The settlement "removes the worst-case scenario" of potentially double-digit royalty rates, said Jefferies analyst Andrew Tsai, adding that it also eliminates any future royalty risk for Moderna’s upcoming COVID and COVID/flu combo vaccines. The deal is positive for Moderna because the total payment works out to a very small share of the company's roughly $48 billion in past global vaccine sales, matching Moderna's earlier expectations, Tsai said. Moderna had been set to defend against Genevant and Arbutus' patent infringement allegations at a trial in Delaware federal court starting the week of March 9. The case would have been the first to go to trial from a web of high-stakes U.S. patent lawsuits over COVID vaccine technology that has also ensnared Pfizer and its German partner BioNTech as well as other drugmakers. Genevant and Arbutus filed a similar lawsuit against Pfizer and BioNTech over the LNP technology in their vaccine in 2023. That lawsuit is still ongoing. Moderna has separately sued rivals Pfizer and BioNTech for infringing patents related to mRNA technology. BioNTech countersued Moderna in February, arguing Moderna's next-generation COVID-19 shot, MNEXSPIKE, infringes one of its patents. Companies including GlaxoSmithKline, Bayer and Alnylam Pharmaceuticals have also filed patent lawsuits seeking shares of the tens of billions of dollars in COVID vaccine sales. (Reporting by Kamal Choudhury in Bengaluru and Blake Brittain in Washington; Editing by Alan Barona and Bill Berkrot)

DOJ abandons defense of orders targeting law firms

Summary: The DOJ voluntarily dismissed appeals against rulings blocking Trump’s executive orders targeting law firms on March 2. Trump issued executive orders aimed at law firms that hired his perceived foes or took on cases he disliked. Four law firms—WilmerHale, Jenner & Block, Perkins Coie, and Susman Godfrey—successfully sued to block the orders as unconstitutional. The administration had faced a March 6 deadline to file its opening brief before dropping the appeals. The Trump administration on March 2 abandoned its effort to punish several law firms that hired President Donald Trump’s perceived foes or took on cases he disliked, effectively admitting defeat and allowing sanctions on the firms to remain blocked by judges. Trump last year issued executive orders targeting multiple law firms, saying they should lose government contracts and their employees must be blocked from government buildings and excluded from government jobs. His actions sparked immense upheaval within the legal industry. Nine law firms reached agreements with Trump to avoid similar penalties, leading some of their attorneys to quit in protest and enraging many others across the profession. While those firms made deals with Trump, four others — WilmerHale, Jenner & Block, Perkins Coie and Susman Godfrey — sued to challenge Trump’s actions after he took aim at them. Judges sided with all four, blocking Trump’s orders targeting them and lambasting those orders as unconstitutional and retaliatory. The Trump administration had appealed all four rulings. On March 2, the administration moved to end its effort to challenge the rulings. In a brief filing that did not explain why the administration had reversed course, government attorneys wrote that they “respectfully move to voluntarily dismiss these consolidated appeals.” The executive orders targeting law firms were all issued during the initial months of Trump’s second term. When U.S. District Court Judge John D. Bates struck down Trump’s executive order targeting Jenner & Block in May 2025, he wrote that it “makes no bones about why it chose its target: it picked Jenner because of the causes Jenner champions, the clients Jenner represents, and a lawyer Jenner once employed.” Trump’s order focused on Jenner singled out the firm’s employment of Andrew Weissman, who had been a deputy to Robert S. Mueller III, the special counsel who investigated Trump during his first term. Weissman left the firm in 2021. Trump also targeted WilmerHale and highlighted that Mueller and two of his deputies had gone on to work there after the special counsel probe ended. Mueller and one of the deputies also retired from that firm in 2021. He also singled out Perkins Coie’s work representing the campaign of Hillary Clinton, his opponent in the 2016 presidential election, and said Susman Godfrey “spearheads efforts to weaponize the American legal system and degrade the quality of American elections.” Susman Godfrey represented Dominion Voting Systems in a defamation lawsuit against Fox News related to untrue claims it aired about the 2020 election, which Trump and his allies have falsely claimed he won. The firms that sued to fight Trump’s orders hailed the administration’s decision. “The Government has capitulated, which is a fitting end to its plainly unconstitutional attack on Susman Godfrey and the rule of law,” Susman Godfrey said in a statement. “In doing so, it has abandoned any attempt to defend the indefensible executive order against our firm.” WilmerHale said the administration’s “decision to dismiss its appeal is clearly the right one.” Jenner & Block said the move “makes permanent the rulings of four federal judges that the executive orders targeting law firms, including Jenner & Block, were unconstitutional,” while Perkins Coie thanked those who had supported the firm since it was targeted nearly a year ago “and all who stand for the rule of law.” The Trump administration has defended the president’s executive orders, describing them as needed to rein in “rogue law firms” and saying in court that they were not meant as punishments. Trump has not issued any new executive orders aimed at law firms since targeting Susman Godfrey last April. The administration has criticized the rulings striking down Trump’s executive orders regarding the law firms, calling them “erroneous” and describing the president’s actions as lawful. The White House referred a request for comment on the abandoned appeals to the Department of Justice. Spokespeople for the department did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the decision on March 2. The Trump administration had faced a looming deadline in the appeal of the cases before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. The DOJ’s opening brief in the case was due by March 6, while the four law firms’ briefs were due at the end of the month. The Wall Street Journal first reported that the administration planned to drop the appeals. Legal experts have expressed deep skepticism of the executive orders, with some saying they doubted appeals would be successful. Trump’s campaign against specific law firms prompted hundreds of others across the industry to speak out, warning that his actions would intimidate attorneys and firms and scare them out of challenging the administration. Many attorneys also expressed deep alarm at the agreements Trump reached with some of the country’s most prominent and wealthiest law firms. The firms pledged a combined nearly $1 billion in pro bono work for causes the administration said it supports, including helping veterans. Firms that made those deals defended them as needed to stay in business, but they prompted outrage within their own offices. Attorneys have left some of the firms in protest, and others have moved from places that made deals with Trump to offices that challenged him. “This episode will be remembered as demonstrating the difference between institutions that had the ethical courage to uphold the Constitution and fight bullying and then won, and those that compromised their ethics and gained nothing,” Vanita Gupta, who served as associate attorney general during the Biden administration, said in a statement.

FBI ransacks mansions, Michigan property tied to church, leaders say

AT A GLANCE Federal raids targeted Kingdom of God Global Church properties in Michigan, Texas and Florida, with church officials alleging more than $133,000 in property damage. The FBI and IRS seized over $4.2 million in cash, gold, jewelry, vehicles and cryptocurrency, prompting a federal court fight over return of the assets. Church leaders, including David Taylor, face forced labor and money laundering conspiracy charges, with prosecutors alleging workers raised $50 million for leaders’ luxury purchases. The church claims the seizures are crippling operations, forcing cuts to charitable programs and jeopardizing its $8.6 million Tampa mansion, while prosecutors argue the assets are evidence in a pending criminal case. Federal agents ravaged Kingdom of God Global Church properties in Michigan and two other states, smashing doors, breaking equipment, destroying security cameras, and causing more than $133,000 in damages while prosecutors have put such a stranglehold on finances that the church is struggling to maintain operations, the religious group's lawyers said. Federal court records describe the fallout from a high-profile probe involving FBI and Internal Revenue Service agents and a fight with the federal government over more than $4.2 million, jewelry, gold coins, silver and foreign currency seized by investigators. Church lawyers are trying to force the government to return the money and assets seized amid an investigation into allegations that church leaders forced workers to raise approximately $50 million and blew the money on mansions, exotic vehicles and other luxuries. Since a series of federal raids, the church is planning to curtail charitable giving and is facing the prospect of losing its $8.6 million mansion in Tampa, Florida, a 28,000-square-foot estate where 25 workers live and train. The church has virtually stopped providing medical care for about 75 pastors, student ministers and volunteers and defaulted on the Tampa mortgage amid a broader financial crisis that threatens to prevent leaders from fulfilling the Kingdom of God Global Church's religious mandate, the group's lawyer argued. "The church cannot function if it cannot pay to support its students and pastors, or for its physical properties," Kingdom of God Global Church lawyer Jorin Rubin wrote in a petition filed with U.S. District Court Judge Terrence Berg. The impact of losing that money has been compounded, church officials said, by the trail of destruction left by FBI agents during the August raids at church properties in Taylor, Texas and Florida. The legal battle also raises questions about whether a church, which has not been charged with a crime, should be endangered because of alleged wrongdoing by its leaders. "Here, the government’s seizure of the church’s assets substantially burdens its religious exercise by preventing or impeding worship services, limiting religious education programs, restricting charitable and community outreach activities, and impeding other faith-based activities central to the church's mission," Rubin wrote. The money fight sheds light on a high-profile investigation and complex criminal case that has portrayed the church as a cult and leader David Taylor as a violent and dangerous sextortionist who coerced women, mostly parishioners, into sending him 50,000 sexually explicit images. The August raids and asset seizures unfolded across the church's sprawling real estate empire. The church owns mansions, homes, a hotel and commercial buildings across at least four states, including Michigan. Damages listed FBI agents raided several properties in August and left a costly reminder that the church documented in a list filed in federal court. • At the Taylor church, federal agents caused more than $40,000 damage by breaking doors, breaking drywall and smashing the security system, church director Kearisten Jones wrote in a declaration filed in court. • Investigators destroyed more doors at a former hotel in Houston owned by the church. Investigators broke fire and pool gates, ruined an irrigation system and damaged 12 air conditioners during the raid. Damages exceeded $57,000, Jones wrote. • At the Tampa mansion, which previously belonged to the co-owner of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, agents broke a sliding glass door and a gate, damaged the elevator and trashed rooms. In all, approximately $20,300 worth of damage. •  At a church-owned home in Ocala, Florida, agents caused more than $11,000 worth of damage, including shooting the 12-foot front door off its hinges and breaking a security system. "... During the raid, the FBI broke open my safe and took my personal belongings, including my passport, Social Security card, birth certificate, my personal phones and gifts I have received throughout my years of service to Jesus," Jones wrote. Prosecutors are fighting the return of any seized money or assets, including five vehicles, a Bitcoin wallet and a boat. Feds resist return of seizures The church's request to recoup the assets is premature, considering there have not been any convictions in the case, prosecutors argued. Criminal charges are pending against three people. Taylor and former Northville resident Michelle Brannon, the second-highest-ranking leader of the church, are charged in a 10-count indictment with conspiracy to commit forced labor, forced labor and conspiracy to commit money laundering. If convicted, they face up to 20 years in prison for each charge, as well as fines of hundreds of thousands of dollars. A third Kingdom of God Global Church leader, 53-year-old Riverview resident Kathleen Klein, was charged in mid-February for her role in the alleged forced labor conspiracy. Prosecutors said Klein, who is known as "Prophetess," served as an enforcer, punishing workers for failing to raise money and threatening eternal damnation. Klein is charged with one count of conspiracy to commit forced labor, a felony with a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison. "The extravagant purchases made by Taylor and Brannon — including gold, jewelry, and luxury goods — are evidence in the criminal case and must be preserved while the case is pending," Assistant U.S. Attorney Adriana Dydell wrote in opposing the church. A spokeswoman for the U.S. Attorney's Office declined to comment about the allegations involving property damage. Taylor and Brannon headed a church with Michigan operations based in a commercial building near Interstate 75 and Northline Road in Taylor. The ministry’s website invites people to donate to help the church bring "the lifesaving and miracle-working power of Jesus Christ to the world through broadcasts, mission outreaches, and worldwide crusades.” The money fight emerged in late December. That is when the church sued to recoup seized assets. "... The continued retention of the church’s assets is causing substantial hardship to a legitimate business’ operation,” Rubin wrote. "... The seizure implicates heightened constitutional and statutory protections under the First Amendment and Religious Freedom Restoration Act, requiring the government to demonstrate a compelling interest and least restrictive means before continuing to burden the church’s religious exercise through retention of its assets as well as the disruption of its members’ ability to freely practice their chosen religion." What federal agents found The church's riches were obvious at the Tampa mansion. When investigators raided the mansion in late August, they found $500,000 worth of gold bars in a locked safe and $60,000 in a closet in a bedroom belonging to Brannon, Taylor's top lieutenant. They also found expensive designer clothing and purses, jewelry, foreign currency, seven Mercedes-Benz vehicles, and two Bentley sedans. Brannon is portrayed as the queen of the church who slept in a room with a crown above the bed. She also served as one of the group's enforcers, according to the government, teaming with Taylor to create a climate of fear through psychological manipulation and violence. Her lawyer, John Rogers, has criticized the government's "thin case," saying there was no evidence people were beaten. He disputed the government's description of church members being held hostage, noting several members of the church have appeared in court to support Brannon, and said members were free to come and go from the group's churches and living quarters. The properties are used for church gatherings, religious services, volunteer operations, administration, housing and boarding members, and providing space for missionaries. "Since the seizure of the church's funds, the amenities available to the individuals living in the church's housing has been reduced," church bookkeeper Jessica Cross wrote in a court affidavit. "The church still provides housing, but the food budget has shrunk and the availability of funds for extra services, such as medical care, have been virtually eliminated." The cost of releasing the seized assets to the church while charges are pending against the trio would be "extremely high," wrote Dydell, the prosecutor. "Specifically, the government would be unable to prevent the spending of the assets acquired by Taylor and Brannon’s forced labor, and (the church) would be able to freely dissipate the assets acquired by criminal activity," Dydell wrote.  This article originally appeared on The Detroit News: “FBI ransacks mansions, Michigan property tied to church, leaders say”